Headshot

As noted in a previous post (see: ‘Last Stand at Isandlwana’), following the battle of Nyezane (22 January 1879) Private Fred Butler of the 2/24th and the 2nd Squadron Imperial Mounted Infantry served throughout the rest of the Zulu War, probably seeing action again with his unit at the Battle of Gingindlovu (2 April 1879). Though they were not involved in the climactic battle at Ulundi, the 2nd IMI did take part in the search for the fugitive Zulu King Cetewayo after the battle. Butler also got his name in the local press one more time before returning home when a few brief accounts of local men in Zululand were noted in the Sentinel. In it Butler sang the praises of their much-criticised commander-in-chief, Lord Chelmsford, who had been widely blamed for the Isandlwana disaster.

‘Frederick Butler, son of Mr. Butler, of the Bell and Bear lnn, Shelton, writing on July 13th to his parents, makes special reference to the esteem in which Lord Chelmsford is held by the general body of soldiers at the seat of war, observing that they look upon him as “a brave and reliable man.”  He also, speaks the hardships the soldiers have to encounter, but gives also the bright as well the dark side of warfare in Africa.’

Butler returned to the 2/24th regiment on 12 September 1879. For his service in the war he was later awarded the South Africa Medal with the 1877-78-79 clasp.

After the war, Private Butler remained in the army until the 1880s. He then returned home to the Potteries and on 23 August 1888 at Holy Trinity Church, he married Mary Jane Smith. At the time he was residing at 12 Brook Street. The couple would have two children. By 1891 Fred seems to have taken over the running of the Bell and Bear Inn in Shelton from his father. He may also have joined the local rifle volunteers whose drill hall still stands at the top of College Road, Shelton. In this capacity he got his name in papers one last time in 1889, in a dangerous, but slightly humorous incident that was related in the Sentinel.

‘A DANGEROUS PRACTICE.

RIFLE SHOOTING AT SHELTON.

 DAMAGES £20.

At the Hanley County Court on Wednesday, before his Honour Judge Jordan, an action was tried and decided, in which Frank Guildford, an engraver, living in Queen Anne-street, Shelton, sued to recover £50 damages from Fred Butler, William Butler, of the Bell and Bear Inn, Shelton; Sidney Smith, cabinet maker, Piccadilly; and J. W. Ault, sign writer, Snow Hill, for personal injuries.

Mr. Boddam. instructed by Mr G. H. Hunt, appeared on behalf of the plaintiff; and Mr. Ashmall defended. £10 had been paid into Court, with a denial of liability.

Mr. Boddam stated that the action was for damages done to the plaintiff being shot by the defendants. – The plaintiff was engraver, and was in the employ of Mr. Fennell, of Mollart-street, Hanley. the 2nd of May the defendants were practising shooting in a garden connected with Cleveland House, which was in the possession of Mr. Butler, of the Bell and Bear Inn. They were shooting with a Morris tube, a species of invention with which persons were in the habit of practising shooting at targets. The tube carried a small bullet to a tremendous distance. The plaintiff at the time was walking down the public road at the rear of Cleveland Gardens, and as he was so walking was shot in the head by a bullet, which he thought he (the learned counsel) could clearly demonstrate was projected by one the defendants. Two operations were found to be necessary to get out the bullet, and plaintiff had to remain away from his work for a fortnight. He had sustained a considerable shock to his system.

The plaintiff stated that about a quarter past one o’clock on the 2nd May he was walking along Lime Kiln Walk with two other persons, when he was hit on the left temple with something. He began to bleed, and found that he had got a hole in his head. Directly afterwards the sound of bullet was heard. It struck some boards near where he was standing, and was afterwards taken out the wood.

His Honour: The bullet hit plaintiff’s head and grazed it ?

Mr. Boddam: No; it went in and stayed there. Luckily for the plaintiff his skull was so thick. (Laughter.)

The plaintiff continued that after seeing the police he went to Mr. Charlesworth who attended him until the end of the month. Mr. Charlesworth took out a portion of the bullet on the 4th May, and the remaining portion on the 20th May.

Mr. Boddam stated that they had any number of admissions of liability.

Mr. Ashmall said his clients were anxious to act generously with the plaintiff.

Mr. J. Charlesworth deposed to extracting the bullet, most of which he took out the 4th May.

His Honour; Let me look at it.

Mr. Boddam: You will see how admirably it was flattened by the gentleman’s skull. (Laughter)

His Honour: A good job for him that he had got so thick a one.

Mr. Charlesworth proceeded to say that the bullet was very bright and slightly grooved, from which circumstances he concluded that it had hit something else before striking the plaintiff; that in fact it was a richochet shot. The bullet lay one inch from the point of entrance.

His Honour: Was it in a dangerous position ?

Mr. Charlesworth: Not in very dangerous position. The wound was too high to be very dangerous: it struck on the thick part the skull. There would be no permanent injury.

His Honour observed that the wrong being admitted, the only point for him to consider was the amount damages.

Mr. Ashmall explained that two of the defendants were volunteers. The garden in which they were practising was ninety-five yards in length. There were palings at the bottom of it. On the other side of these palings was plantation twelve yards deep. This was bordered by another fence and beyond it, before the road was reached, was a field 300 yards in length, also bordered by a railing. The guns were sighted for 100 yards, he suggested that this bullet struck one of the trees, from which it glanced and then hit the plaintiff. There was nothing absolutely illegal in what the defendants were doing, and as soon as inquiries came to be made the defendants went so far to say that they would pay any reasonable compensation.

His Honour said it was difficult matter to measure damages in a case of this sort. No doubt whatever that the defendants were engaged in a dangerous pursuit, and had they killed the plaintiff, would, he dared say, have been put upon their trial for manslaughter. The damages sustained by plaintiff were not serious, but still it was a dangerous thing to have bullet sent into his head. He thought that in giving a verdict for £20 and costs, he was giving a very moderate sum indeed.’

This, though, is the last occasion on which we hear anything about Fred Butler, who appears to have died quite young, aged 33 in 1891.

Staffordshire Sentinel and Commercial & General Advertiser, Saturday 23 August 1879. p.4; Thursday 06 June 1889, p.3. Information on Pvt Butler’s service from Forces War Records and Rorkesdriftvc forum. My thanks to 1879zuluwar forum members Kate (a.k.a ‘gardner1879′), John Young, ’90th’ and Julian Whybra for further information on Frederick Butler.

Comments

2 responses to “Headshot”

  1. 12 axes avatar

    Following Private Fred Butler from Nyezane through Gingindlovu and the search for Cetewayo, rather than stopping at the famous disaster of Isandlwana, is a careful way to keep one soldier visible across the rest of the war. I like that the piece also notes what his unit did not do at Ulundi, instead of letting a career absorb every climactic battle. I run 12 axes, a free political values test, and I value history writing that stays with ordinary people inside a larger political conflict.

  2. Gary Cooper avatar

    Thank you. My background, having worked in a couple of industrial museums, makes me quite sympathetic towards the smaller figures in history, be it workers in a pot bank or pit, or some poor soldier stuck in the middle of a war he knows little about. I agree with you, history isn’t just about big names, no matter their impact.

Leave a Reply