
Source: Wikimedia Commons
The year 1799 was very cold and wet. The winter of 1798/1799 had been a harsh one, which was followed by an extremely cold spring that held the country in its icy grip well into early summer, stifling blossom and killing off early plants. Only in June was there any respite when for a few short weeks the cold faded and the sun prevailed, but foul weather returned with a vengeance as summer waned into autumn. From August to September, it poured down incessantly, the combined tally of 378.9 millimetres (14.92 inches) of rain making them the two wettest consecutive months in British history. Rivers and streams were in near constant spate and many lowland areas suffered from severe flooding. Crops were ruined and flocks cut off from their farmers died in the fields.
While upland areas like North Staffordshire were spared the worst of the flooding, the land was still waterlogged. Roads were undermined or turned into quagmires and even the normally trustworthy and well-maintained turnpike roads began to suffer in the deluge. If anyone had hoped that October would bring any relief they were disappointed, for though the rains relented a little, they gave way to storms and harsh frosts in the first days of the month that only exacerbated the problems. Suffice to say, conditions being what they were, it was not a good time to be a traveller.
Despite these problems, early in the morning between 7 and 8 o’clock on 8 October, the Liverpool to Birmingham stage coach came rattling along the turnpike road from Newcastle-under-Lyme bound for Stone. It was a typical heavy covered wooden stage coach of the time, perhaps brightly coloured and lettered according to the owner’s want and designed to carry passengers and luggage. The coach had a central compartment for the passengers who sat facing each other on padded leather seats – this coach could seat six – while outside the coachman sat up high at the front and the guard at the rear, both perched above the front and rear boots where parcels and luggage were stored. On the roof were four ‘rumble seats’ where extra passengers could sit for a smaller fee. All of this equipage was suspended by thick leather straps to a strong wooden undercarriage that ran on four large spoked wooden wheels, all of which was pulled along by a team of four horses running their latest stage of about 15 miles on to their next rest stop.
On top this morning were three passengers including the regular driver who was ill, the guard at the rear and a replacement driver up front, who was the horse keeper from the inn at Stone. Inside there were six passengers, a sailor, two respectable gentlemen (some sources say two sailors and a respectable gentleman) plus a married couple, the lady’s maid and the couple’s pet spaniel. The latter three people were 61 year old Andrew Robinson, 40 year old Sarah Robinson and their servant, a 26 year old woman named Rebecca, whose surname is difficult to make out in the surviving documents, but may have been a phonetic rendering or misspelling of the name Hayes. The Robinsons were returning from a six week tour to Scotland to visit friends there and were now taking the long haul back to their home in Duke Street, St James, in London. Andrew Robinson, was a man of some note in the city, boasting a long career in the Royal Household that on his demise earned him an obituary in The Gentleman’s Magazine.
‘Mr. Robinson’s employments were in the services of the first personages in the kingdom; and he executed them with that fidelity, promptitude and exactness, which gained him the approbation of all, and even their confidence. He was for many years in the Prince of Wales’s family, as one of his gentlemen ushers and under-treasurer; and was likewise under-treasurer to the Dukes of York and Clarence, and the younger princes. When the Prince’s establishment was broken up, his Royal Highness as a mark of his esteem, settled a pension of 500l a year on him, which he enjoyed until his death.’
Mr Robinson was furthermore described as a humane, friendly, upright man and his wife Sarah as a worthy and benevolent woman. The lady’s maid, Rebecca, was doubtless a trusted servant to have been travelling along with her employers, but the other actors in the drama that was about to unfold, remain sadly anonymous figures.
The turnpike road out of Newcastle took them to Tittensor, two miles south of Trentham, where they were meant to cross the Trent before moving on to Stone. The river was high, swollen by run-off from the recent rains, but it was not impinging on the road, which was lined with a railing fence along the river bank. What exactly happened next is open to debate as the surviving witnesses at the coroner’s inquest a few days did not enter into details as to what had transpired. However, a month later The Gentleman’s Magazine carried the following account of what happened and why,
It was the fault of the replacement driver, the Magazine roared, one of ‘the deplorable cases which too frequently happen by the carelessness of stage-coach drivers.’ Had the coachman driven with care there would have been no problem, but the passengers started to grow increasingly concerned as they went along, that the man was driving the coach much too close to the railing. One of the passengers spoke to the coachman telling him to keep further away from the railing and when one of the wheels struck a post he ‘sharply remonstrated’ with the man, but got the tart reply that there was no more danger than on a floor. The driver’s blasé attitude, continued and hardly a minute passed after this, than he took the coach too near to the weakened bank one more time, which suddenly gave way under the fore-wheel and the coach, horses and passengers crashed through the railing and plunged over the edge of the bank into the river.
The coachman, guard and passengers on the roof were immediately flung into the water and managed to scramble over to the bank. For those trapped in the carriage, though, escape was a more difficult matter and unsurprisingly it was the sailor (or one of them) who was the first to clamber his way from the inside of the coach. He helped the other two single male passengers out then pulled Arthur Robinson out; but seeing Sarah Robinson and her maid in difficulties, he left Mr Robinson who was unfortunately unable to get to the shore and was quickly swept away downstream. The sailor meanwhile swam back to the coach and attempted to get Rebecca out, but despite his best efforts he could not free her, as Mrs Robinson clung so desperately to her maid and from sheer exhaustion the sailor was obliged to leave them, barely managing to struggle ashore himself.
A few minutes later the sailor saw that Rebecca had managed to extricate herself and was floating down the river. Calling to the others on the bank to try and save the maid, he bravely went back in to get Mrs Robinson out, not doubting that the men would rescue the younger woman. This they might have achieved if they had had presence of mind to find a large branch or stick for her to grab a hold of, but before they had time to think of the solution she was out of reach. The sailor meantime managed to pull Mrs Robinson back to the bank. She was unconscious, but still warm when he carried her over to a nearby cottage, however, she was too far gone and died soon afterwards. Half an hour later, the body of her maid Rebecca was found downstream, where she had died hanging by both hands from a willow branch. Of Arthur Robinson there was no sign, but he too had perished, his remains being found further down the river the following evening. It is not made clear if the Robinson’s dog had survived, but dead or alive the engraved collar on the animal later provided the means to identifying the three dead people; the coach and presumably living horses were subsequently remanded to the lord of the manor.
On 11 October a coroner’s inquest was held before J. Dickenson, Gent., on the bodies of the three deceased, but as already noted, the witnesses were still too shaken by events to give any detailed account of what happened. This begs the question as to how the editor of The Gentleman’s Magazine got such a blow-by-blow account, or why the carelessness of the driver was overlooked and seemingly went unpunished, and how the bravery of the sailor passenger went unrecognised even by simply being named. Yet, the facts do fit with the bare account given in papers such as the Staffordshire Advertiser, so are probably correct. A month had gone by, so perhaps the information had since been hunted out from one or more of the survivors.
Whatever the case, the inquest returned a verdict of accidental death on the three and their bodies were removed for burial that same day at St Giles Church in Newcastle under Lyme. The burial register records them as ‘Artha Robison’, Sarah Robison’ and ‘Rebecca Yheys’, giving their ages and date of burial, along with the brief note, ‘the above three, Husband + Wife and Servant were all kild by the Coach being turned over in the River at Tittensor Heath and all drowned.’
Reference: The Gentleman’s Magazine, November 1799, pp.908, 909 and 991; Staffordshire Advertiser 12 October 1799, p.4 & 19 October p.4.

Leave a Reply