Though by 1819 the gang of street thugs known as the Rough Fleet had been effectively stricken from the streets of the Potteries, trouble still abounded across the region. Groups of young men out on the town still got themselves into fights and occasionally committed worse crimes and fell foul of the law. One such incident occurred in late 1819 when Daniel Collier (aged 18), William Toft (21), William Holford (17), John Walklate (24) and John Cooper (22) were arrested and on 11 December were committed to Stafford Gaol for the rape of one Hannah Bowers at Stoke-upon-Trent. At the subsequent trial at the Stafford Assizes on 20 March 1820, evidence was presented that Bowers was hardly the most sterling character, she had been highly intoxicated on the night in question and only a few days after the alleged assault she had suggested to the men that each of them should pay her £2 which would have been ‘a sufficient compensation for the violation of her person’ – which to many hardly seemed the reaction of a genuine rape victim and more that of a prostitute. The price, (though described as ‘a trifling sum’ in one newspaper report) was far too much for the youths, who were poorly paid potters and miners and they refused to cough up and so Hannah Bowers bought the charge of rape against them. This was when things got serious, as rape if proven, was at that time a capital crime answerable with ‘a more dreadful sacrifice’ than a few pounds, namely the death penalty.
To the shock of many in the district, despite the evidence against Bowers as a loose woman, the five young men were all quickly found guilty of rape and sentenced to death. Hasty petitions were made on their behalf to the presiding judge and also to the Home Secretary in hopes of prevailing on the King for mercy. A few days later from Shrewsbury, Judge Richardson forwarded reprieves for John Cooper and William Holford, but Collier, Toft and Walklate were only granted a fortnight’s stay of execution. Then on 12 April, a letter came from the Home Secretary stating that the matter was such that it could not be referred to His Majesty and the law must follow its due course. The condemned men took the news calmly, Walklate for one had been convinced the petitions were pointless, though Collier and Toft had apparently held out hopes for a last minute reprieve.
On Friday 14 April, the men were visited by the prison Chaplain who remained there all day, preparing them for what was to come. In the afternoon, John Walklate (who seems to have been the most thoughtful and religious of the group) asked to say a few words to the other condemned prisoners and was allowed to do so. In a calm manner he urged the men to mend their ways if they were spared the gallows and to serve God and he asked them to pray for him. The Chaplain then left the three youths to whatever fitful sleep they could get that night.
The next morning at 6 o’clock, they were roused and taken to the Chapel to receive the Sacrament and stayed there until 8 when the prison bell began to toll and they were led up to the scaffold above the gatehouse. Below, a large crowd had gathered to watch and as it was a controversial sentence and there was the possibility of trouble, a party of the Sheriff’s officers on horseback with drawn swords and thirty special constables were on hand to keep the crowd in order and ensure the execution went unhindered. Toft ascended the scaffold first followed by Walklate and Collier. Whilst they were being readied by the hangman, the Chaplain, at Walklate’s request, exhorted the crowd ‘to refrain from the destructive vices of sabbath-breaking and blasphemy’ that had ultimately led them down a dark path to the gallows. During this harangue the three prisoners prayed fervently and as they were expressing the words ‘Lord remember me’ at about 8.05 a.m., they were dropped. Walklate died instantly, Toft struggled a little, while Collier writhed for some time on the rope. After hanging for an hour the bodies were cut down and were delivered to their waiting family and friends to be taken back to the Potteries for burial.
So much for the tale as related in the newspapers of the time, though Henry Allen Wedgwood expanded on the story, charting the life and fate of John Walklate, whom he erroneously names in his account as ‘William Walklate’. He describes the man as a religious convert who had however fallen back into his old vices and paid the ultimate price as a result of his relapse. As an addendum to the tale, Wedgwood also relates that on the drive back to the Potteries the carrier who transported the bodies of the three hanged men found that John Collier was still breathing and hurried on to Hanley in hopes that he might receive attention, but on arriving it was found that Collier had expired. Toft, Walklate and Collier were said to have been buried under the path to Hanley Churchyard, a great crowd turning out for their funerals.
Henry Allen Wedgwood, People of the Potteries pp. 47-52; Staffordshire Advertiser 11 December 1819, p.4; 25 March 1820, p.4; 15 April 1820, p.4; 22 April 1820. p.4; Aris’ Birmingham Gazette, 20 March 1820. p.3.













